If Every Person’s Sustenance has been Decreed, then why are Some (found to be) Hungry?

English Us

If Every Person’s Sustenance has been Decreed, then why are Some (found to be) Hungry?

8751 1 share 0

Verse 6 of Surat Hud says:

There is no moving creature on earth but its sustenance depends on God. [11:6]

In view of the above verse, the question that comes to mind is: Why it is that in today's world and all throughout history there are some, who have died and continue to die of hunger? Have their livelihoods not been secured and safeguarded?

 

The answer to this questions demands attention towards the following points:

Firstly: Securing sustenance does not mean that it should be made ready for a person and sent to his house or a morsel prepared and put into his mouth; rather, it means that the groundwork has been prepared, but man's effort is a condition for transforming them into actuality. Even Maryam (s.a.), in that severe state of labour in that lonely desert wherein Allah (s.w.t.) ordained her sustenance to become manifest in the form of dates upon the date-palm, was ordered to move and addressed as follows:

وَ هُزِّي إِلَيکِ بِجِذْعِ النَّخلَةِ…
“And shake towards you the trunk of the palm tree, it will drop on you fresh ripe dates.”1

Secondly: If, in the past and the present, men have usurped the rights of others and have taken their livelihoods from them unjustly, this does not prove that Allah (s.w.t.) has not secured their livelihoods. In other words, in addition to the issue of effort and striving, the existence of social justice is also a condition for a just distribution of sustenence.

And if it were to be said: Why does not Allah (s.w.t.) prevent the injustices perpetrated by the unjust ones? We state that the life of man is based on the freedom of will so that all are tested and examined, and not on force and compulsion - for in such a case the development and perfection (of man) would not take place.

Thirdly: In this very earth there exist numerous sources that can provide nutrition to mankind, but which need to be discovered and put to use. However, if man exhibits negligence in this regard, he is the one to be blamed.

We ought not to forget that some areas of Africa, the inhabitants of which die of hunger today, are amongst the most enriched regions of the world. However, destructive factors, which were mentioned above, have brought them to this miserable state of theirs.2

1. Surat Maryam (19), Verse 25
2. Tafsir Payam-e-Qur’an, vol. 2, pg. 357

Related Post

Types of God's Justice

Types of God's Justice

There are various ways in which Divine Justice is expressed as regards the three...

Were all the Companions of the Noble Prophet (S) Upright and Righteous?

Were all the Companions of the Noble Prophet (S) U...

Some of the Sunni brothers, due to the respect and importance attached to the 'f...

A Brief Biography of the Eleventh Imam; Hassan Ibn Ali al-Askari (as)

A Brief Biography of the Eleventh Imam; Hassan Ibn...

...Imam al-‘Askari pointed at one of the monks and ordered the soldiers to take ...

Sermon 94 of Nahj al-Balagha: Allah's praise and eulogy of the prophets

Sermon 94 of Nahj al-Balagha: Allah's praise and e...

Exalted is Allah Whom heights of daring cannot approach and fineness of intellig...

The Meaning of Self-Knowledge and Its Significance

The Meaning of Self-Knowledge and Its Significance...

Self-knowledge implies knowledge about the Lord as well. Awareness of one's self...

Ways of Recognizing the Prophets

Ways of Recognizing the Prophets

Primordial human nature compels man not to accept any claims without conclusive ...

Who are the ‘Twelve Imams’?

Who are the ‘Twelve Imams’?

A set of hadiths narrated by our Sunni brothers about twelve successors of the P...

What is the main philosophy of Imam Mahdi’s occultation?

What is the main philosophy of Imam Mahdi’s occult...

One of the most important Shiite principles is the belief in the occultation of ...

Comments

Please share your comments with us.

0 Comments

Blog Categories

IslamPlus Events Article Ahlulbayt View