Imam Kazim's Debate with Harun about Fadak

Sign in English Us



Imam Kazim's Debate with Harun about Fadak

5735 1  share 0

In some cases, we come across certain claims and remarks in the statements of the infallible Imams which are unusual. Such remarks underline a specific goal and strategy, which is in fact the Imamate strategy. The debate of Imam Kadhim (as) and Harun about Fadak is among such issues:
Once Harun told Imam Kadhim (as): "Please mark the area of the "Fadak" (the land property of Hazrat-e Fatima (SA) which was unjustly usurped) so that we return it to you."
Harun was thinking that by returning the Fadak[1] to the Imam, he would be able to disarm him of the slogan of Fadak, which was a proof of the injustice done to the Progeny of the holy Prophet (SA). He was also thinking that through this measure, he would be able to draw a comparison between the Abbasside and the Umayyad who had once taken away the Fadak from them.

The Imam first refrained from marking the limits of the Fadak, but when Harun insisted, he said: "If you are to return the Fadak, you must accept its true borders." Harun accepted the offer. Then the Imam started explaining the borders of the Fadak, saying: "Its first border is Aden."
This debate was going on between the Imam and Harun in Medina or Baghdad. The Imam continued: "Its other side is the Arabian Peninsula." Harun's face turned pale, and said, "oh!" The Imam said: "Its other border is Samarkant," that is, the eastern extremity of Harun's realm. Harun's face turned red. "And its third border is Africa," the Imam said. The third border, Africa (Tunisia), was the western extremity of Harun's realm. Harun exclaimed, "Strange!?" Finally, his holiness said, "Its fourth border is a coastline, behind the islands and Armenia," that is, the northern extremity of Harun's realm.
Infuriated Harun said satirically: "In this case nothing will remain for me, come and take my seat." Imam Musa al-Kadhim (as) said: "I told you that if I mention the limits of the Fadak, you would not return it to me!" The tradition adds at the end: "it was here that Harun decided to assassinate the Imam."1
The most outstanding issue in this debate is the contention of Musa ibn Ja'far, which Harun realized well and decided to assassinate the Imam. Such remarks reveal the contentions of the Imams, which are clearly seen in the lives of Imam Baqir (as), Imam Sadiq (as) and Imam Ridha (as). An overall analysis of such claims delineates the Imamate strategy.

[1] Fadak is the name of a garden which was given to lady Fatima by the prophet Muhammad, but after the demise of the prophet it was taken from her by the caliph that time.

Related Post

How to Make Good Friends?

How to Make Good Friends?

“O you who have believed, do not take My enemies and your enemies as allies, ext...

Sermon 106 of Nahj al-Balagha: About Islam

Sermon 106 of Nahj al-Balagha: About Islam

Praise belongs to Allah, who established Islam and made it easy for those who ap...

Tawassul (Intermediary Causes) according to the Shi'ite school of thought

Tawassul (Intermediary Causes) according to the Sh...

The life of man is constructed on the basis of making use of various intermediar...

Taste the heat of fire! (story)

Taste the heat of fire! (story)

Tired and exhausted with the waterskin on her back, she was gasping and going to...

31) Imam Sajjad's Supplication in Repentance

31) Imam Sajjad's Supplication in Repentance

This is the station of him whom sins have passed from hand to hand. Offenses' re...

Today, Humanity Needs the Holy Qur'an

Today, Humanity Needs the Holy Qur'an

The blessings of the Holy Quran are endless. There is dignity, power, progress, ...

Short Biography of Hadrat Fatima Masoumah (AS)

Short Biography of Hadrat Fatima Masoumah (AS)

on the 10th of Rabi al-Thani of the year 201 AH, after 28 years of sufferance an...

Comments

Please share your comments with us.

0 Comments

Blog Categories

IslamPlus Events Article Ahlulbayt View