OneHadith

English Us
Fundamental Beliefs » Human and Human » Prophets » God's Manifest and Inward Proofs over People
الإمام الكاظم (عليه السَّلام):
إنَّ للّهِِ عَلَى النّاسِ حُجَّتَينِ : حُجَّةً ظاهِرَةً ، و حُجَّةً باطِنَةً ، فأمّا الظّاهِرَةُ فَالرُّسُلُ و الأنبِياءُ و الأئمَّةُ عليهم السلام ، و أمّا الباطِنَةُ فَالعُقولُ .

Verily Allah has two authoritative proofs over people: a manifest proof and an inward proof. The manifest proof is [represented by] the prophets and messengers and Imams (as), and the inward proof is intellect.
Source: al-Kāfī Vol1 P16
ID: 27236

6259 0 share

Divine proof, or hujjat, is how God holds His servants accountable and seeks answers. Those who act contrary to it will be condemned.

Reason is an inner proof that illuminates the path and informs us of right and wrong. Prophets and imams are divine proofs. Divine scriptures are proofs from God, as are pure and pious individuals.

Those who lack reason and are unaware of their actions have no obligation and will not be held responsible for them. According to the Quran, God will never punish a people until He sends a messenger among them.

Through the sending of prophets, the revelation of scriptures, and the instilling of reason within humans, God has completed His proof against them. Let's act in a way that will prevent us from being condemned in the divine court on the Day of Judgment.

 

This profound statement by Imam al-Kazim (peace be upon him) articulates the concept of divine guidance and the means through which God establishes His authority and truth among people. The Imam outlines two essential forms of evidence—one outwardly apparent and the other inwardly recognized—highlighting the relationship between divine revelation and human reason.
 
Key Themes and Reflections
1. Two Forms of Divine Proof
The hadith distinguishes between two types of divine proof that God provides to humanity:
  • Manifest Proof (حُجَّةً ظاهِرَةً): This includes the prophets, messengers, and Imams, who serve as visible representatives of God’s will and guidance. They bring messages of truth, ethics, and divine instruction to humanity, acting as clear signs of God’s existence and authority.
  • Inward Proof (حُجَّةً باطِنَةً): This refers to human intellect and reason. The innate ability to think, reflect, and discern right from wrong is a gift from God, allowing individuals to understand truth and morality independently. This intellectual capacity serves as an internal guide to recognize and accept the truths revealed through the manifest proofs.
2. The Role of Prophets and Imams
The mention of prophets and Imams as the manifest proof emphasizes their critical role in guiding humanity. They convey God’s messages, clarify moral and ethical standards, and exemplify the qualities that believers should aspire to emulate. Their teachings provide a framework for understanding one’s purpose and responsibilities in life.
3. The Importance of Intellect
The reference to intellect as the inward proof signifies that God has endowed human beings with the ability to reason and reflect. This intellectual faculty allows individuals to seek understanding beyond mere acceptance of religious teachings. It encourages critical thinking and the pursuit of knowledge, fostering a deeper relationship with faith. The intellect can help validate the prophets' messages and recognize their truth.
4. Harmony Between Faith and Reason
By presenting both manifest and inward proofs, the Imam highlights the harmony between faith and reason. True belief is not blind acceptance but is supported by understanding and reflection. The coexistence of divine guidance through prophets and the rational abilities bestowed upon humanity forms a comprehensive approach to faith that encourages believers to engage actively with their beliefs.
 
Practical Implications
  1. Seek Knowledge and Understanding: Believers are encouraged to deepen their understanding of faith by studying the teachings of prophets and Imams while also using their intellect to explore and reflect on these teachings.
  2. Balance Between Revelation and Reason: Recognize that both divine revelation and human intellect are essential for a well-rounded understanding of spirituality. Engage in discussions and reflections that integrate both dimensions.
  3. Embrace Critical Thinking: Use your God-given intellect to question, analyze, and seek answers. This approach strengthens one’s faith and helps dispel doubts or misconceptions.
  4. Recognize the Role of Guidance: Acknowledge the importance of prophets and Imams as guides in your spiritual journey. Their teachings can provide clarity and direction in navigating life’s challenges.
 
Conclusion
Imam al-Kazim’s statement encapsulates a fundamental principle of faith: the duality of divine proof through manifest and inward means. By recognizing the roles of prophets and the power of intellect, believers are encouraged to engage actively with their faith. This dynamic interplay between revelation and reason fosters a deeper understanding of God’s guidance, ultimately leading to a more profound and fulfilling spiritual journey. This hadith serves as a reminder that faith is not merely about belief but also about understanding, reflection, and the pursuit of truth.

Ask a Question

General Data

The full information of the hadith is given below

infalibel
Imam al-Kazim (as)

Source Data

The full information of the hadith is given below

title
al-Kāfī
author
Abū Jaʿfar, Muḥammad b. Yaʿqūb b. Isḥāq al-Kulaynī Al-Rāzī (Arabic: ابوجعفر، محمّد بن یعقوب بن اسحاق الرازی) (c. 255/868-9 - 329/941) was among the greatest Shi'a hadith scholars and the author of al-Kafi, the most authentic Shi'a hadith collection and one the Four Books. He was born after the martyrdom of Imam al-'Askari (a), at the time of Imam al-Mahdi (a) and met some hadith transmitters who directly had heard hadiths from Imam al-Hadi (a) and Imam al-'Askari (a). It is said that al-Kulayni was very accurate in transmitting hadiths. Ibn Qulawayh, Muhammad b. Ali Majilawayh al-Qummi, Ahmad b. Muhammad al-Zurari were among his students.
year
1386
publisher
Dar al-Hadith

Multi Media

You can watch the latest clips in this section:

Comments

Please share your comments with us

0 Comments